Which is the Best Choice, of Greenhouse Building & Construction Planning, Glass Greenhouse Plans or Polycarbonate Greenhouses Plan?
Post Category: Greenhouse Articles > Building Greenhouses > Greenhouse Components & Parts > Glass and Polycarbonate > Material and Cost Comparison
Greenhouses are classically made
from aluminum and glass, but recently, some people are substituting the glass
for twin wall polycarbonate.
- The mega trend toward producing your own vegetables is leading more growers to experiment with different materials and expand beyond traditional options.
- Plastic greenhouse construction materials include fiberglass, polyethylene film, and polycarbonate.
Polycarbonate has numerous advantages over glass, including:
1. Greenhouse Insulation Ability:
Successful greenhouse plant growing is a matter of keeping the plants at the right temperature.
- Glass is not a very efficient material when it comes to heating, because it transmits heat and cold too rapidly.
- People have made use of glass’s difficulty retaining heat in other structures, from thermometers to spoons, but it is a disadvantage in other areas.
- Greenhouse glass panels are usually double or triple the normal thickness of glass to provide enough insulation, which can be problematic.
 |
| Polycarbonate |
At the right thickness, polycarbonate sheets retain heat better than horticulture glass.
- Polycarbonate sheets can lengthen the plants’ growing season, which can make all the difference in plant production.
- Twin polycarbonate sheets are structurally similar to thermal windows, and provide a similar benefit.
- They can reduce heating costs when compared to glass-paneled greenhouses, due to their greater heat retention abilities.
A material’s thermal insulation value is its ‘R’ value: Horticulture glass that’s three millimeters thick has a lower R-value than four-millimeter twin-wall polycarbonate sheets.
Single layer polycarbonate sheets have a reduced R-value compared to glass, so it is important to take grades and measurements into account, and not to substitute single layer polycarbonate sheets for twin layer polycarbonate sheets.
- A higher R-value can make all the difference for the plants, particularly when growing during the autumn and winter.
- The R-value will increase in proportion to the thickness of the twin panel polycarbonate walls.
2. Greenhouse Structural Durability:
Glass is famously fragile.
- Polycarbonate sheets can withstand far more pressure and shocks than glass, including fallen tree branches, hail, heavy storms, and the impact from incoming tennis balls.
- Growers with nearby trees, active wildlife, or bustling neighbors may want to invest in polycarbonate sheets.
- Twin polycarbonate sheets are also highly flame resistant, in case of emergencies.
- On average, twin polycarbonate sheets last for fifteen years under ideal conditions.
- Greenhouses made from glass require substantial repairs over the course of their own lifetimes.
3. Ease of Greenhouses Assembly:
Polycarbonate sheets are not as heavy as glass, and do not have to be cut specially to fit the greenhouse specifications.
Glass is heavier than many other building materials, and needs the sort of significant framing structure polycarbonate sheets do not. Glass also must be kept completely rigid during construction. Often times, amateur growers cannot construct glass greenhouses themselves, and must procure the services of a contractor. Polycarbonate sheets are more conducive to individual assembly.
4. Internal Light Penetration:
There is a risk of burning plants when using glass-paneled greenhouses, because glass does not effectively diffuse light.
- Polycarbonate sheets are constructed to have a ribbed texture that breaks ultraviolet rays.
- The texture of polycarbonate sheets diffuses the incoming ultraviolet light, all the better for plant growth.
- The diffused light minimizes shadow, so growers can take full advantage of incoming light and not have to compensate on behalf of the plants.
- Some plant species need more or less light, and could be most efficiently grown in a greenhouse made from twin-walled polycarbonate.
 |
| Materials: Made with Glass |
5. Reduction in Inside Greenhouses Condensation Levels:
Twin polycarbonate sheets have been tested in conditions of eighty percent humidity, with a fifty degree temperature differential between the outside and the inside of the greenhouse.
- There was still no condensation on the greenhouse glass.
- Greenhouse condensation is more important in regards to aesthetics, but a buildup of moisture can still be problematic.
 |
| Greenhouse Materials: Made with Polycarbonate and Plastic Roof |
 |
| Glass Greenhouse Panels: Materials |
 |
| Glass Hot House: Sun-room Greenhouse Conservatory Elegant Style |
 |
| Basic Hobby Greenhouse: Built with 6mm Twin Wall Polycarbonate Panels |
 |
| EarthCare Greenhouses Brand: Basic Hobby Greenhouse 6' x 6' Kit w/ 4mm Polycarbonate |
Growers can also take advantage of
both materials, and get greenhouses constructed from a combination of glass and
polycarbonate.
- Some growers still prefer glass greenhouses for sentimental reasons.
- Advances in materials science will create a portfolio of options for greenhouse growers and hobbyists.
There are some very common models that not only will be relatively easy to construct based on the plans available, but are also inexpensive.
